[an error occurred while processing this directive]

I-Team looks into reports of shaken baby syndrome

Updated: Saturday, May 24, 2014 |
I-Team looks into reports of shaken baby syndrome story image
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (NEWSCHANNEL 3) - With several high-profile cases centering on child abuse charges related to shaken baby syndrome in courts across West Michigan right now, the Newschannel 3 I-Team is taking a closer look at the science both prosecution and defense depend on.

A pediatrician at Spectrum Hospital in Grand Rapids told Newschannel 3 that unfortunately all pediatricians are confronted with shaken baby syndrome on a regular basis, but the medicine only goes so far toward proving child abuse.

She says doctors must become detectives themselves.

We examined the issue through the case of war vet Anthony McFarlane and his baby Kaydence.

"Anthony took the girls over to his mothers house where she was going to watch them," said Kaydence's mother Dakota Chitwood.

She adds that while there, Kaydence started having seizures, so her grandparents drove her to the hospital.

"Whenever I got there, I walked in to Kaydence seizing," Chitwood said. "That was the hardest thing I've ever seen."

Three months later, McFarlane was charged with first degree child abuse.

"You have the doctors from the children's hospital try to put a time as to when the injury occurred and then the police officers charge based upon that information," McFarlane's new attorney Elias Muawad said via phone Friday.

Muawad says he's argued in more than a dozen cases that the process is a crapshoot.

"It's not an exact science, and to try to pinpoint the exact time that this child was hurt, if it was shaken baby, in my opinion is virtually impossible," he said.

So we went to Spectrum Hospital to talk to pediatrician Dr. Abeba Berhane.

"It's a very difficult one to diagnose, because some times it can go unnoticed for a few hours, up to a few days," she said.

Dr. Berhane says pinpointing the time and cause of injury is a challenge.

"You can have accidental head trauma that can occur, you can have bleeding disorders," she said.

Back in December, doctors told Chitwood that they found the left side of Kaydence's brain was completely underdeveloped--a situation they attributed to strokes she suffered while in the womb.

"Any time you have damage to the brain, shaken baby syndrome, stroke, hypoxic injury; all those things can show up as brain injury," Dr. Berhane said.

Dr. Berhane says that's why the story becomes very important, as do other injuries the child may have suffered such as bone fractures and contusions.

For example, according to family, baby Kaydence had a healing spiral fracture in her leg when doctors suspected shaken baby syndrome.

This is one of the things McFarlane's attorney says  his experts will discuss in court.
comments powered by Disqus
advertisement

What do you want to see?

If you have a story idea for the I-Team, you can contact us using the form below or by calling 269-388-4612.
Please re-enter the code shown in the image below.

Business News

Last Update on August 29, 2014 17:14 GMT

CONSUMER SPENDING

WASHINGTON (AP) -- U.S. consumer spending fell in July, with a drop in auto purchases accounting for most of the weakness. Income growth also slowed in July.

The Commerce Department says consumer spending edged down 0.1 percent last month after a 0.4 percent increase in June. It was the first decline in spending since January. Income growth slowed to a 0.2 percent rise in July, the weakest showing in seven months.

The fall in spending came primarily from a decline in auto sales, which took a breather in July after posting big gains in recent months, although spending in other areas was also weak.

Consumer spending accounts for 70 percent of economic activity, so it needs to recover for the economy to keep its momentum in the second half of the year.

CONSUMER SENTIMENT

WASHINGTON (AP) -- U.S. consumer sentiment ticked up in August, driven by greater optimism about jobs, rising incomes, and increasing wealth. The increase largely occurred among higher-income groups.

The University of Michigan says its index of consumer sentiment rose to 82.5 from 81.8 in July. Still, it has barely risen in the past year.

Consumers have sent mixed signals in recent months. The Michigan index has fluctuated between 80 and 82.5 since December. A measure of consumer confidence by the Conference Board rose this month to nearly a seven-year high. And yet Americans cut back their spending in July.

Nearly 60 percent of households in the top third of income earners say they are financially better off this month, the Michigan survey found, compared with only 36 percent in the bottom two-thirds.

US-FIAT-CHRYSLER

DETROIT (AP) -- U.S. investors should soon be able to buy stock in Chrysler for the first time in seven years.

Italy's Fiat and Chrysler are merging to form Fiat Chrysler Automobiles. Fiat says Friday that an ongoing tally of investors suggests there is not enough opposition to derail the deal.

Earlier this month, Fiat shareholders approved combining the companies. But Italian law gives dissenters the right to cash out. Fiat has said that if investors offered more than 500 million euros ($650 million) in shares, the merger would be off.

Fiat SpA will announce the final tally by Sept. 4. So far the maximum number of shares to be cashed is below the cap.

Shares of Chrysler haven't been publicly traded since 2007 when it was still combined with German automaker Daimler.

REYNOLDS AMERICAN-LORILLARD

RICHMOND, Va. (AP) -- Federal regulators are putting Reynolds American Inc.'s planned $25 billion takeover of rival cigarette maker Lorillard Inc. under the microscope.

The nation's second-biggest tobacco company said Friday that the Federal Trade Commission has asked for additional information as part of an antitrust review of the deal.

In July, Reynolds announced the deal to combine two of the nation's oldest and biggest tobacco companies, creating a formidable No. 2 to rival Altria Group Inc., owner of Philip Morris USA.

Reynolds markets Camel, Pall Mall and Natural American Spirit cigarettes. Lorillard sells Newport, Maverick and Kent cigarettes.

The companies plan to sell the Kool, Salem, Winston, Maverick and blu eCig brands to Imperial Tobacco Group for $7.1 billion to ease regulatory concerns about competition.

HEALTH OVERHAUL-TAX FORMS

WASHINGTON (AP) -- The federal agency that brought you the glitchy HealthCare.gov website has a massive new project.

If the Health and Human Services department has trouble this time, that could delay tax refunds for many people.

Complicated connections between the new health care law and income taxes will start to surface in 2015.

HHS has to send millions of people who got health insurance tax credits this year a new tax form that's like a W-2 for health care. It's called a 1095-A.

If they're delayed beyond Jan. 31, people who got coverage through the new insurance exchanges may have to wait to file their taxes -- and collect their refunds.

Some tax preparation companies are worried.

The Obama administration says it's on task, but won't provide much detail.

EUROPE-ECONOMY

BRUSSELS (AP) -- Inflation has fallen to an annual 0.3 percent in August for the 18 countries that use the euro, underlining the shakiness of the continent's economic recovery.

Eurostat, the EU statistics agency, says the figure is down from 0.4 percent in July, as expected by market analysts.

Core inflation, which excludes volatile food and energy, sent a modestly brighter signal as it rose to 0.9 percent from 0.8 percent.

The eurozone economy showed no growth in the second quarter as fears about the Ukrainian crisis weighed on consumers and investment decisions.

The European Central Bank has warned that inflation expectations are worsening and says it will add more stimulus if needed. Many analysts are predicting the bank will launch large-scale purchases of financial assets to pump more money into the economy.

BRAZIL-ECONOMY

SAO PAULO (AP) -- Brazil's government says the country's gross domestic product contracted 0.6 percent in the second quarter compared with the previous three months, sending the country's economy into a recession.

The government's IBGE statistics bureau said Friday it was the second consecutive quarterly contraction of the economy.

In the first quarter of the year, GDP was reported as having grown 0.2 percent. But that figure was revised downward to minus 0.2 percent.

The IBGE says the country's GDP stands at 1.27 trillion reals ($567 billion).

advertisement