[an error occurred while processing this directive]

I-Team looks into reports of shaken baby syndrome

Updated: Saturday, May 24, 2014 |
I-Team looks into reports of shaken baby syndrome story image
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (NEWSCHANNEL 3) - With several high-profile cases centering on child abuse charges related to shaken baby syndrome in courts across West Michigan right now, the Newschannel 3 I-Team is taking a closer look at the science both prosecution and defense depend on.

A pediatrician at Spectrum Hospital in Grand Rapids told Newschannel 3 that unfortunately all pediatricians are confronted with shaken baby syndrome on a regular basis, but the medicine only goes so far toward proving child abuse.

She says doctors must become detectives themselves.

We examined the issue through the case of war vet Anthony McFarlane and his baby Kaydence.

"Anthony took the girls over to his mothers house where she was going to watch them," said Kaydence's mother Dakota Chitwood.

She adds that while there, Kaydence started having seizures, so her grandparents drove her to the hospital.

"Whenever I got there, I walked in to Kaydence seizing," Chitwood said. "That was the hardest thing I've ever seen."

Three months later, McFarlane was charged with first degree child abuse.

"You have the doctors from the children's hospital try to put a time as to when the injury occurred and then the police officers charge based upon that information," McFarlane's new attorney Elias Muawad said via phone Friday.

Muawad says he's argued in more than a dozen cases that the process is a crapshoot.

"It's not an exact science, and to try to pinpoint the exact time that this child was hurt, if it was shaken baby, in my opinion is virtually impossible," he said.

So we went to Spectrum Hospital to talk to pediatrician Dr. Abeba Berhane.

"It's a very difficult one to diagnose, because some times it can go unnoticed for a few hours, up to a few days," she said.

Dr. Berhane says pinpointing the time and cause of injury is a challenge.

"You can have accidental head trauma that can occur, you can have bleeding disorders," she said.

Back in December, doctors told Chitwood that they found the left side of Kaydence's brain was completely underdeveloped--a situation they attributed to strokes she suffered while in the womb.

"Any time you have damage to the brain, shaken baby syndrome, stroke, hypoxic injury; all those things can show up as brain injury," Dr. Berhane said.

Dr. Berhane says that's why the story becomes very important, as do other injuries the child may have suffered such as bone fractures and contusions.

For example, according to family, baby Kaydence had a healing spiral fracture in her leg when doctors suspected shaken baby syndrome.

This is one of the things McFarlane's attorney says  his experts will discuss in court.
comments powered by Disqus

What do you want to see?

If you have a story idea for the I-Team, you can contact us using the form below or by calling 269-388-4612.
Please re-enter the code shown in the image below.

Business News

Last Update on October 30, 2014 17:28 GMT


WASHINGTON (AP) -- The U.S. economy grew at a solid annual rate of 3.5 percent in the July-September quarter, propelled by solid gains in business investment, export sales and the biggest jump in military spending in five years.

The Commerce Department says that the third quarter result followed a 4.6 percent rebound in the second quarter. The economy shrank at a 2.1 percent rate in the first three months of the year due to a harsh winter.

The report was the first of three estimates of the gross domestic product, the economy's total output of goods and services. Economists believe the economy is maintaining momentum in the current quarter with consumer spending expected to be helped by a big fall in gas prices.


WASHINGTON (AP) -- The number of people seeking unemployment benefits rose slightly last week, but remained at historically low levels that signal a strengthening job market.

The Labor Department says weekly applications increased 3,000 to a seasonally adjusted 287,000. The four-week average, a less volatile measure, declined 250 to 281,000, the lowest level in more than 14 years.

Applications are a proxy for layoffs and have fallen 20 percent in the past year. The steady decline suggests that businesses are sufficiently confident in the economy to hold onto their staffs. That same confidence could lead them to step up hiring.

The economy expanded at a solid annual rate of 3.5 percent in the July-September quarter, according to a separate government report. That's healthy enough to encourage more hiring.


WASHINGTON (AP) -- Average U.S. long-term mortgage rates arrested their five-week decline this week but the benchmark 30-year loan remained below 4 percent.

Mortgage company Freddie Mac says the nationwide average for a 30-year mortgage rose to 3.98 percent from 3.92 percent last week. It remained at its lowest level since June 2013. The rate stood at 4.53 percent back in January.

The average for a 15-year mortgage, a popular choice for people who are refinancing, increased to 3.13 percent from 3.08 percent.

The sustained decline in long-term rates sparked a boomlet of homeowners looking to refinance mortgages. Homeowners eager for a bargain rate fired off inquiries to lenders. Applications for "re-fi's" reached their highest level since November 2013 in the week ended Oct. 17, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.


WASHINGTON (AP) -- Federal regulators are suing baby food-maker Gerber for claiming that its Good Start Gentle formula can prevent or reduce allergies in children.

The Federal Trade Commission says that claim is bogus and that the New Jersey-based company misled consumers by suggesting the formula was the first to meet government approval for reducing the risk of allergies.

The FTC says it wants Gerber to remove that claim from formula labels and advertisements. The agency also wants Gerber to reimburse consumers who have bought the formula since 2011, when the claim began.

Gerber Products Co., also known as NestlT Infant Nutrition, says in a statement that it believes it has met all legal requirements about product claims.


NEW YORK (AP) -- Wal-Mart Stores Inc. is considering matching online prices from competitors like Amazon.com, raising the stakes for the holiday shopping season.

The world's largest retailer, based in Bentonville, Arkansas, has matched prices of local store competitors but hadn't followed moves by other retailers like Best Buy or Target to match prices of online rivals. It said it has been testing the strategy in certain markets and is trying to figure out whether to go ahead.

The strategy comes as Wal-Mart is trying to rev up sluggish sales in the U.S. but it could also erode profits.

A Wal-Mart spokeswoman says many store managers have matched online prices for customers on a case-by-case basis.

The move was first reported by The Wall Street Journal on Thursday.


UNDATED (AP) -- Microsoft is looking to challenge Apple and Google with its own system for consolidating health and fitness data from various fitness gadgets and mobile apps. Microsoft is also releasing a $199 fitness band to work with this system.

As more athletes and recreationalists track their fitness, a chief frustration has been the inability to bring data from one gadget into an app made by a rival. As a result, nutrition information might reside in one place, while data on calories burned might be in another. Consolidating data gives users and health professionals a bigger picture on health.

Microsoft Health follows the launch of Apple's HealthKit in September and Google Fit earlier this week. Unlike rival systems, Microsoft Health will work with competing phones, not just those running Windows.


MADRID (AP) -- Spain's parliament has approved new intellectual property laws that allow news publishers to charge aggregators each time they display news content in search results.

The law goes into effect Jan. 1 but does not specify how much aggregators like Google News could be charged. Spain's AEDE group of news publishers had lobbied for what is known as the "Google Tax" but has not provided specifics.

Google Inc.'s Spanish division said Thursday it was disappointed with the outcome and will work with Spanish news publishers to help them increase income.

Google last year agreed to help French news organizations increase online advertising revenue and fund digital publishing innovations to settle a dispute there over whether it should pay for news content in its search results.


BEIJING (AP) -- Chinese computer maker Lenovo Group has completed its acquisition of Motorola Mobility from Google Inc. in a move aimed at becoming a global smartphone brand.

Lenovo said it completed the $2.9 billion purchase on Thursday, adding to a flurry of acquisitions and initiatives aimed at transforming the world's biggest maker of personal computers into a major player in wireless computing.

Google bought Motorola Mobility in 2012 for $12.4 billion but appeared to decide quickly the purchase was a mistake. It sold its set-top operations to Arris Group Inc. for $2.35 billion and its smartphone assets, along with some 2,000 patents, to Lenovo.

Lenovo chairman Yang Yuanqing said when the purchase was announced in January that it would help transform Lenovo into a global competitor in smartphones.