[an error occurred while processing this directive]

More documents, allegations emerge in Battle Creek overtime flap

Updated: Friday, January 10, 2014 |
More documents, allegations emerge in Battle Creek overtime flap story image
BATTLE CREEK, Mich. (NEWSCHANNEL 3) - After the Newschannel 3 I-Team looked into allegations of time card fraud in Battle Creek's City Hall, the City Manager is calling foul.

Last week, the I-Team reported that the Department of Labor is investigating allegations from employees that their time cards are being deliberately changed to save money.

Thursday night, the I-Team uncovered an email sent by the City Manager to all Battle Creek employees.

In it, he says his comments were "misrepresented" in order to "sensationalize" the story.

Since the email, more Battle Creek employees have come forward with documentation to support their claims.

It's typically a matter of about 10 minutes, they say, usually in the morning or possibly after lunch, but they say it easily adds up to a couple of hours a week.

And even at $8 per hour, that's more than $1,000 per year for each employee.

They say they're sick of it, and that's why they went to the Department of Labor.

They all say the same thing: they're "required to be in early" to prepare for their shifts, but when they enter the actual start time, they find their supervisor "scratched it off" their time card.

"If that's the case, we need to make sure that doesn't happen unless there is truly an error in the time card to begin with," said Battle Creek City Manager Ken Tsuchiyama last week, when first asked about the allegations.

It was at that time when he told Newschannel 3 that the allegations were first brought to his attention around 3 weeks prior.

Internal correspondence obtained by the I-Team, however, indicates that whether City Manager Tsuchiyama knew it or not, overtime increments being being recorded incorrectly has been an issue since at least last winter.

But in no way does it prove fraud.

"In my mind, that means that we are going back and changing an employee's, someone is changing an employee's time card," Tsuchiyama said.

A notice from Battle Creek Employee Services explains employees must be paid for every tenth of an hour, or as little as four minutes on the clock, but employees tell Newschannel 3 that the treasurer ignored that.

They provided an email sent from the Treasurer exclusively to employees in the Treasury and Water Billing Departments, saying "tenths should not show up on the time cards."

So, employees stopped coming in ten minutes early as ordered, because they weren't being paid for it.

But they claim, "when you come in just a couple of minutes early, she writes you up for being late."

We called several Battle Creek city commissioners, as well as the Mayor, looking for comment on the story, but it was after 5:00 p.m., and we haven't heard back from any of them at this time.

We left a voicemail for City Manager Tsuchiyama, who replied by email. He said in part:

"I don't know what you're hearing from employees, but until we have things in final form from the (Department of Labor), I really have no comment.

"Sorry you found my email message to employees disappointing, but I obviously was, and am, disappointed with your report," he added.

To see our full interview with City Manager Tsuchiyama, click here.
comments powered by Disqus
advertisement

What do you want to see?

If you have a story idea for the I-Team, you can contact us using the form below or by calling 269-388-4612.
Please re-enter the code shown in the image below.

Business News

Last Update on July 06, 2015 17:13 GMT

GREECE-BAILOUT

ATHENS, Greece (AP) -- A top Greek official says the government is "moving immediately"" to reach a deal with its creditors "as soon as possible" in order to stave off economic collapse.

Government spokesman Gabriel Sakellaridis said Greek Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras has sought support from all political party leaders and that the government is "fully aware of how crucial the situation is."

Tsipras met with rival party leaders a day after Greeks soundly rejected a proposal by creditors for more austerity measures in exchange for rescue money.

Sakellaridis said the leaders couldn't ignore the people's message for a viable deal that would be fair to the poor, deal with Greece's massive debt and restore liquidity to the hobbled banking system.

GREECE-BAILOUT: IMF

ATHENS-Greece (AP) -- International Monetary Fund head Christine Lagarde says the fund stands "ready to assist Greece if requested to do so."

Her statement is the IMF's first reaction to Sunday's decision by Greek voters to reject further austerity measures in return for bailout loans.

Greece is in arrears to the IMF, having failed to pay a 1.5 billion-euro ($1.7 billion) loan due last Tuesday. The IMF said it couldn't get involved in a further bailout of Greece if the country remained in arrears.

The IMF last week also said that Greece would need debt relief as well as new financing worth more than 60 billion euros through 2018 to avoid financial collapse.

Greece is expected to meet with its creditors tomorrow.

GREECE-BAILOUT-REACTION

ATHENS, Greece (AP) -- On the streets of Athens, Greeks are proud of their toughness and defiance after Sunday's landslide "no" vote against creditors' demands -- but they acknowledge there's still plenty to worry about.

George Papadokostakis, a 34-year-old coffee shop owner, says he's very happy with the referendum result. He says "something happened last night with the Greek people. ... we were in a dead-end situation (but) with the `no' vote we believe there may be something better."

Shoe store worker Nicky Zachary thinks Greeks are tough and united in rejecting austerity. She says "we can live with very little and we can live through difficult situations. And I think after the referendum, the Greek people are united."

GREECE-BAILOUT-TSIPRAS

ATHENS, Greece (AP) -- Greece's defense minister says three opposition parties have signed a declaration backing Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras (TSEE'-prahs) in bailout negotiations with creditors.

That makes a total of five parties behind the prime minister, who already had the support of his own Syriza (SEER'-ih-zah) party and the junior party in the governing coalition, the Independent Greeks.

Defense Minister Panos Kammenos says the support heralds a "new era" in Greek politics and would boost Athens' chances of reaching a deal with European and international creditors.

Tsipras convened a meeting of party leaders today, a day after winning a bailout referendum that rejected creditors' previous demands. Following the vote, Greece's finance minister resigned, and he's already been replaced.

GREECE-BAILOUT: FINANCE MINISTER

ATHENS, Greece (AP) -- The Greek government has named Euclid Tsakalotos as the country's new finance minister, a day ahead of an emergency meeting with creditors in Brussels.

The 55-year-old economist was Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras' lead bailout negotiator in talks that halted last month before Tsipras called a bailout referendum. In that referendum, Greeks overwhelmingly voted against recent creditor proposals required for bailout cash.

Tsakalotos replaces fellow-economist Yanis Varoufakis who quit earlier Monday, saying his departure would help bailout negotiations reach an agreement.

GREECE-BAILOUT: FITCH

UNDATED (AP) -- Credit ratings agency Fitch says Greece's `no' vote in Sunday's austerity referendum "dramatically increases" the risk of the country leaving the eurozone.

Fitch said a deal between Greece and its creditors remains possible but that there's little time. The agency said the resignation of Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis signals the Greek government's desire to again start talking with its creditors.

It said creditors could make stronger commitments on easing Greece's huge debt but were unlikely to make big concessions on austerity measures. In addition, Fitch said the European Central Bank may find a way to provide hobbled Greek banks with additional liquidity while negotiations continued.

Markets steadied on the news of Varoufakis' resignation to not register further falls. Germany's DAX ended 1.5 percent lower, while the euro was up 0.8 percent on the day just below $1.11.

ECONOMY-SERVICES

WASHINGTON (AP) -- U.S. service firms grew at a slightly faster pace in June, as business activity and new orders increased.

The Institute for Supply Management says its services index edged up to 56 in June from 55.7 in May. Any reading over 50 indicates that services firms are expanding.

Steady hiring over the past year has fueled a consumer spending rebound from a winter slump. Many economists say the economy will expand at an annual rate of 2.5 per cent in the second quarter, after shrinking during the first three months of 2015.

Still, the index's hiring component slipped in June to 52.7 from 55.3 in May, which indicates that the rate of job growth might slow.

JAPAN-HONDA

TOKYO (AP) -- Honda's new CEO is promising to take more time in product development, and to bring his company together as a team to avoid the quality lapses that have led to shrinking profits at the Japanese automaker.

Takahiro Hachigo, an engineer who has worked in the U.S. as well as China, talked to reporters today after his appointment was approved by shareholders and the company board.

Honda's brand image has suffered after a series of massive recalls for popular vehicles in Japan, as well as for defective Takata air bags in global markets.

Hachigo's promise to turn the company around centers on raising the efficiency of global manufacturing and delivering on what he calls Honda-like products. But he's been a little short on specifics.

SKINNY OREOS

NEW YORK (AP) -- These Oreos are for adults. That's what the parent company of the Nabisco treat is saying about the new "Oreo Thins."

Mondelez International says Oreo Thins still have the same cookie to cream ratio, but they're thinner. And each cookie is 140 calories as opposed to the 160-calorie regular Oreo cookie.

Mondelez calls Oreo Thins a "sophisticated" snack for grown-ups that isn't meant to be twisted or dunked.

The thinner cookie joins the permanent lineup of Oreo cookies starting next week in the U.S.

advertisement