Saugatuck-Douglas and lack of trust in government
Updated: Thursday, October 31 2013, 08:11 PM EDT
KALAMAZOO, Mich. (NEWSCHANNEL 3) - There's a huge ballot item on Tuesday for voters in the West Michigan tourist cities of Saugatuck and Douglas.
The question is at once simple and complex: should the two communities consolidate their governments?
Tonight in Tom's Corner, Tom Van Howe says it's a question that ought to have an easy answer, but has been made difficult by the very same fears and forces that have polarized our entire country.
Here's an even bigger question: if these two lakeshore communities, who have different identities, but share so many similarities, can't figure out how to save money and increase efficiency by merging their governments, who can? Anywhere?
Here we are on a dreary Halloween night, and nothing conjured up by even the most diabolical trick-or-treater can hold a candle to the polarization of this country—and along with it the fear and distrust of government.
It's a fear and distrust, by the way, that has been incubated by politicians for a long, long time. And we—all of us—are paying the price.
Not that it has a direct bearing on Saugatuck and Douglas, but take a look at today's national polls.
On the heels of the absolutely disastrous roll-out of his signature healthcare bill, President Obama has a 52 percent disapproval rate.
He's nearly as unpopular as George W. Bush was. He's losing the trust of the people.
The people have long since lost their trust in Congress. That gang that can't think straight. The approval rating for the 535 members of the House and Senate has sunk to an astonishing nine percent.
Michael Vick during his dog fighting trial did better than that.
Seventy-or-so percent of the people polled think its time to give somebody else a chance. Whether that translates to incumbents getting tossed out remains to be seen. But he sentiment is there.
None of this is meant to suggest that Saugatuck and Douglas haven't had fine elected leaders. It's just that we live in a time of distrust—of fear, of losing control.
How else can you explain what appears to be a down-to-the-wire vote on an issue that at first glance is a no-brainer?
These two cities already share a police department—a department many residents think is too large and too expensive—a fire department, sewer and water systems, a library, a K-through-12 school system, a harbor commission, and a reliance on tourism for their well being.
All of those mergers made things more cost-efficient. All were considered, and still are, to be smart moves.
Up to five independent studies say the two communities would save roughly half-million dollars a year by merging governments, in part, by having one City Manager and one City Clerk instead of two.
So what keeps the cities from writing the signature chapter? Fear that one government will change the distinct personality of the cities? One Internet commenter expressed fear that there would, under one government, soon be chain hotels and restaurants and the taking of property by eminent domain.
The fact is, residents and governments of both cities have long demonstrated a devoted stewardship of the environment, to quality of life, and a marked resistance to any nationally logoed enterprise.
One former Saugatuck Mayor, a man with whom I often share coffee in the morning, objects because he can't bear the thought of a hyphenated destination called Saugatuck-Douglas.
Not a good reason, Henry.
A former Mayor of Douglas, a restaurant owner, objects because his city isn't broke and doesn't need to be fixed.
He says he's afraid his city will become a spring-break kind of place as he has depicted Saugatuck.
Nice try, Matt, but there's no reason the two cities can't handle that. Larger cities often have "distinctive" neighborhoods.
Yet another former major supports consolidation because it would offer a larger voice to compete more efficiently with other communities. And its hard to argue with that.
On Tuesday, I'll be voting yes. I'll be voting to eliminate duplication of services for a combined population of only 2,300 people.
And I'm going to trust the people we elect to run things to do a good job.
All this polarization has got to stop somewhere. What better place than Saugatuck-Douglas.
In this corner...I'm Tom Van Howe.